Homeowner fined £2,000 and dragged to COURT over privacy fence mistake – know the rules to avoid the same fate

Homeowner Fined £2,000 And Dragged To Court Over Privacy Fence Mistake – Know The Rules To Avoid The Same Fate - Surveyors UK
Share This

A HOMEOWNER has been hit with a £2,000 fine and dragged to court over a mistake with his privacy fence.

Philip Hardy’s wooden fence was no taller than those of his neighbours, he claimed.

A brick house with a car parked in front.

The fence was deemed by the council to block the view of the road[/caption]

Street view of a residential area with cars parked.

Owner Philip Hardy was ordered to remove the fence[/caption]

However, the council deemed that the one-metre structure, which Philip did not have planning permission for, obstructed passing drivers’ view of the road.

The Middlesborough dad-of-two was instructed to remove the fence on November 14 2023 – and given 60 days to respond.

However, he failed to reply, leading to him being taken to court.

Philip told Teesside Magistrates’ Court: “I don’t know why it [the case] has got this far. There are three fences in the road exactly the same as mine.

“I don’t think I have done anything wrong to be truthful with you, that is my honest opinion.”

Philip also denied ignoring the notice, claiming he had tried to organise an appointment with the council following a visit from a local planning officer.

And, he claimed he had even hired a private contractor to reduce the height of the fence.

However, Morgan Brien, prosecuting on behalf of Redcar and Cleveland Council, disputed this claim – by pointing to a wheelie bin pictured next to the supposedly reduced fence.

Philip was found guilty – and fined a total of £180 plus the council’s court costs of £1,972.

He will be allowed to pay the fee in £20 monthly installments, due to being unemployed and on disability benefits.

It comes after another homeowner, Farhan Khan, was slapped with a £622 and criminal record over a similar mistake.

The Southampton man had not applied for planning permission for the one-metre fence.

He applied for retrospective permission but was turned down by the local council.

He was then ordered to tear it down – but refused to do so.

What is retrospective planning permission?

People who build a structure can apply for permission afterwards.

The council can ask the resident to retrospectively apply for planning permission for any completed work which needs it.

This normally happens when someone complains to the council about the new work.

The same considerations will apply and permission only be granted if it is deemed suitable by the local authority.

Retrospective planning applications are not automatically approved – around one in five are turned down.

If the application is turned down, the homeowner may have to tear down whatever they have built.

But if it is approved, the retrospective planning permission is just as valid and legitimate as permission granted before building work starts.

What are your rights over a fence row?

IT’S very important to know your rights if you are embroiled in a fence row with a neighbour.

How do I know which side I own?

A boundary feature can be a fence, wall, hedge, ditch, piece of wire, or sometimes even just the edge of a driveway.

The only way to know for certain who owns what side and to avoid any neighbour disputes, is to refer to the title plan or Land Registry

In this, the T mark is used to indicate who the boundary belongs to and therefore who is responsible for its upkeep, say pros at Jacksons Fencing.

Larger developments tend to have some indication provided by the builder, but there are no hard and fast rules

People often think they are responsible for the left (or right) hand boundary wherever they live, but there isn’t any legal basis for this.

You can check with HM Land Registry to see which boundary feature you are responsible for.

Often households can’t get hold of the paperwork but experts say they shouldn’t panic.

Homeowners can guess who owns the fence by checking where the rails are.

Pros say: “The fence is typically facing away from their property so that their neighbour gets the ‘good’ side. 

“This is the most secure way of facing fencing so there are no rails for anyone to use to climb into your garden. 

“This is then repeated with the neighbour on the other side to ensure that each home has both a ‘good’ and ‘bad’ fence side.”

Walls and fences are often built on the land of the boundary’s owner with the edge of the wall marking the limit.

While professionals agree a glimpse at the fence can give you a hint, it’s not foolproof – so you can’t be certain.

Fines and punishment

It is recommended to always check legal documents before making changes to avoid hefty fines.

There is no law that the neighbour has to get the good side of the fence, so it’s completely up to whoever owns the fence. 

Fencing pros have suggested: “It may be worth selecting a double-sided panel with no ‘bad’ side as both sides look the same and rails are concealed within the fence panel.”

If one boundary backs onto a road or footpath you can install the panels with the rails on the inside

But if it’s installed on the outside, it can provide an “easy ladder for burglars to enter your garden”.

The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) and the Property Litigation Association have created a mediation service to help neighbours resolve disputes over their property boundaries without resorting to court action. 

RICS also provides a list of surveyors who could assist in boundary disputes.

If a dispute continues, it is ultimately a court that makes decisions, but they do not like such disputes being put before them.

Changing a boundary

If you want to change an existing boundary, such as replacing an old fence with a new one, we always recommend discussing with your neighbour first and making sure it is all agreed.

The registered titles can help you to reach an agreement, but only if this information has been added.

In terms of decorations on a fence legal advisers recommended asking around over who actually first installed it.

But they also urged caution before getting to work on amending the fence without getting more certainty yourself – since there is a danger of actually being prosecuted for criminal damage.

How high can a garden fence be?

The height of the fence is measured from your ground level, this can have an impact when, due to slopes in the ground, your garden may be at a higher level than your neighbours‘.

garden fence can be as high as 100m but you need to get planning permission if it’s over than 2m.

However, there are some complications to this.

If you are thinking about front garden fences, restrictions state that fences alongside a driveway can be a maximum of 1m or 3ft.

You would need to get planning permission for putting a trellis on a fence of 2m.

But, if any plant that you grow on that trellis exceeds 2m, you do not need to obtain a permit for the growing plant.

Wooden fence in front of houses.

The one-metre privacy fence in Nunthorpe, Yorkshire[/caption]

Click here to continue reading

Author: AI search for RICS (could be various topics)
Build connections and shape the future
Join Surveyors UK

Surveyors UK is an inclusive membership platform connecting the UK’s surveying community.

Join waitlist

Want us to let you know when we’re ready for our full launch.
Enter your details below, and we’ll email you when we’re ready.